
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Best for families and couples who want extensive on-site amenities (multiple pools, spa, marina) and easy access to downtown Naples.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a Tuscan‑style, marina-front resort in Naples with multiple pools, on-site restaurants, a full spa and marina — good for families and couples who want resort amenities near downtown Naples. Blue Bayou A is a casual Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island) vacation home with basic on-site fitness and nearby marina access — a lower-recognition, budget-friendly option for travelers who want a simple Fort Myers Beach base.
Updated · about 40 miles (≈64 km) apart

Best for families and couples who want extensive on-site amenities (multiple pools, spa, marina) and easy access to downtown Naples.

Best for travelers seeking a straightforward, casual Fort Myers Beach stay with free self parking and local beach access nearby.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: Choose Naples Bay Resort & Marina if you want a full-service resort experience — waterfront restaurants, a dedicated spa, five outdoor pools including a lazy river and adults-only options, scheduled shuttles to the beach and a marina with rentals.
When Blue Bayou A wins: Choose Blue Bayou A if you just need a simple Mid Island Fort Myers Beach vacation home with free self parking, basic fitness options and proximity to several beaches without paying for resort-level services.
Bottom line: Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a higher‑service, amenity-rich resort ideal for guests who plan to use pools, spa and dining; Blue Bayou A is a lower-frills, practical base on Fort Myers Beach for travelers focused on beaches and local exploration.
| Category | Naples Bay Resort & Marina | Blue Bayou A |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Upscale waterfront resort with Tuscan-style grounds and marina | Casual Fort Myers Beach coastal vacation home (single property) |
| Location | Downtown Naples waterfront, walking distance to Tin City and close to Fifth Avenue South | Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island), a short drive/walk to nearby public beaches |
| Size / rooms | 85 rooms and suites, plus separate cottages and villas | Not published |
| Ages / family friendliness | All ages — family pool and lazy river plus adults-only pool areas | All ages (not adults-only); check-in minimum age applies per host policy |
| Pools & water features | Five outdoor pools including a lazy river, zero-entry family pool, lap pool and adults-only pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Nosh on Naples Bay, Blackbird Modern Asian, Indulge, BlueWater Bar & Grill, Café on the Bay) | Not published (no on-site signature restaurants listed) |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Naples Bay Club with massages, facials, sauna/steam and fitness centers | Fitness facilities listed; spa services not published |
| Marina & activities | Private marina with 97 slips; boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals; tennis courts and shuttle service | Marina nearby and easy access to Fort Myers Beach area activities; rentals/organized tours not published |
| Parking & transport | Valet only with daily/overnight fees; complimentary shuttles to beach/downtown/club | Free self parking available; local beaches and attractions within short drives |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in 4:00 PM, check-out 11:00 AM | Check-in begins 4:00 PM, check-out 10:00 AM per listing |
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on Naples Bay in Royal Harbor, minutes from downtown Fifth Avenue South and Tin City.
Choose Naples Bay Resort for a central Naples waterfront base with easy access to downtown and marina activities.
Blue Bayou A is a vacation home in Fort Myers Beach’s Mid Island neighborhood, within short distances of several Fort Myers Beach shoreline spots.
Choose Blue Bayou A for straightforward access to Fort Myers Beach public beaches and Mid Island convenience.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina offers a variety of guest rooms, suites and cottages designed for couples and families.
Naples Bay is best when you want multiple room-size options and marina-front suites for families or groups.
Blue Bayou A is listed as a single vacation home unit with multiple beds.
Blue Bayou A is a single vacation-home option — simple and suitable for travelers wanting one private unit on Fort Myers Beach.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina includes several full-service restaurants and casual outlets around the marina and pools.
Naples Bay works well if you want multiple in-house dining experiences spanning casual to refined.
Blue Bayou A’s supplier listing does not show signature on-site restaurants.
Expect to use local Fort Myers Beach dining options rather than on-site signature restaurants at Blue Bayou A.
Pools and on-water activities are central to Naples Bay Resort’s offering.
Naples Bay is a better pick if pools, a lazy river and marina activities matter to your trip.
Blue Bayou A listing highlights nearby beaches and a marina but does not publish on-site pool details.
Blue Bayou A is for travelers who prioritize beach time over resort pools and on-site water amenities.
Naples Bay Resort combines a dedicated spa, substantial fitness facilities and evening dining/entertainment options.
If spa treatments and a full fitness program are part of your trip, Naples Bay provides on-site services.
Blue Bayou A lists fitness facilities and casual on-property games, but spa and formal nightlife details are not published.
Blue Bayou A covers basic fitness needs; for spa services and resort nightlife plan to go off‑site.

Naples Bay Resort — five pools including a family zero‑entry pool and lazy river plus family-friendly dining.

Blue Bayou A — a simple Mid Island vacation home with free self parking near multiple public beaches.

Naples Bay Resort — full spa (The Spa at Naples Bay Club) and a 2,500‑sq‑ft Wellness & Fitness Center with classes.

Blue Bayou A — walkable/short drives to Sterling Ave Beach and other Fort Myers Beach spots without resort fees.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina — it’s on the Naples waterfront within minutes of Fifth Avenue South and Tin City.
No — Blue Bayou A doesn’t publish on-site pools or a spa; choose Naples Bay Resort if pools and a full spa matter.
Blue Bayou A lists free self parking on-site. Naples Bay Resort uses valet parking for guests with daily/overnight fees.
Naples Bay Resort — it has an on-site marina with 97 slips and direct boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals; Blue Bayou A notes a marina nearby but not on-site rentals.
Explore how Naples Bay Resort & Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·