
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Best for travelers who want resort amenities (multiple restaurants, five pools, spa, marina and shuttle to Naples Beach) in a single property.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a large, all-ages waterfront resort in downtown Naples with multiple pools, a private marina and several on-site restaurants — good for families, couples and travelers who want a full-service stay near Fifth Avenue South. Hawkaritaville is a casual Fort Myers Beach vacation home-style property aimed at beach-goers who want a simple, name-recognizable stay close to Estero Boulevard and local attractions.
Updated · about 40 miles apart

Best for travelers who want resort amenities (multiple restaurants, five pools, spa, marina and shuttle to Naples Beach) in a single property.

Best for budget-conscious beach visitors who want a casual Fort Myers Beach location and simple vacation-home accommodations near local piers and the Key West Express.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: Choose Naples Bay if you want a wide set of on-site facilities — multiple restaurants and bars, five outdoor pools including a lazy river and adults-only options, an on-site marina with boat rentals, a registered spa and fitness centers — all aimed at families and couples seeking a full-service stay near downtown Naples.
When Hawkaritaville wins: Choose Hawkaritaville if you need a straightforward, casual Fort Myers Beach–area vacation home with easy access to Estero Boulevard Beach, nearby attractions like Matanzas Pass Preserve and Key West Express, plus free self parking and a simpler price-point stay.
Bottom line: Naples Bay is the choice for amenity-rich resort stays and waterfront boating activities; Hawkaritaville works when your priority is a compact, beach-area base in Fort Myers Beach rather than full-service resort offerings.
| Category | Naples Bay Resort & Marina | Hawkaritaville |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Tuscan-style, full-service waterfront resort with marina and multiple on-site venues | Casual Fort Myers Beach vacation-home stay |
| Location | Downtown Naples, marina on Naples Bay near Fifth Avenue South | Fort Myers Beach (Donora Blvd), about 0.6 mi from Estero Boulevard Beach |
| Size | 85 rooms and suites plus cottages and villas; large resort footprint | Single vacation-home listing (room type: House, Multiple Beds (Hawkaritaville)) |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-friendly and couples; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages — not adults-only; check-in age not specified in supplier listing |
| Pools & water features | Five outdoor pools including lazy river, zero-entry family pool, lap pool and adults-only pool/whirlpool | Swimming pool (single); nearby beaches and marina access in the area |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site options (Nosh on Naples Bay, Blackbird Modern Asian, Indulge, BlueWater Bar & Grill, Café on the Bay) | Not published |
| Spa & fitness | The Spa at Naples Bay Club (book ahead); 2,500 sq ft Wellness & Fitness Center, plus smaller hotel gym | Not published |
| Known for | Marina with boat/kayak/paddleboard rentals, full resort amenities and shuttle to beach/downtown | Simple beach-area vacation home close to Key West Express and local preserves |
| Parking | Valet parking only (fee); resort fee applies for club access | Free self parking available onsite |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in from 4:00 PM, check-out by 11:00 AM | Check-in begins 4:00 PM, check-out 10:00 AM (supplier listing) |
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on Naples Bay near Fifth Avenue South and Tin City, within easy reach of downtown Naples.
Choose Naples Bay for a central Naples location with immediate marina access and short trips to downtown attractions.
Hawkaritaville is a Fort Myers Beach vacation home on Donora Blvd with beaches and preserves a short drive away.
Hawkaritaville is best if you want Fort Myers Beach access and proximity to local preserves and ferry services.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina offers a range of rooms, suites and cottages across multiple room types.
Pick Naples Bay when you need multiple room types, larger suites or cottages for families or groups.
Hawkaritaville is listed as a vacation home with the single room type 'House, Multiple Beds (Hawkaritaville)'.
Hawkaritaville suits guests seeking a standalone vacation-home layout rather than multiple hotel-style room options.
Naples Bay includes multiple on-site restaurants and a café, covering casual poolside to refined waterfront dining.
If you want multiple on-site dining styles and evening options, Naples Bay delivers more choices than a single vacation home.
Hawkaritaville's supplier listing does not list signature on-site restaurants — dining is likely local or self-catered.
Expect to rely on nearby Fort Myers Beach dining or self-catering rather than multiple hotel restaurants.
Naples Bay's signature amenities are its five outdoor pools and private marina with boat rentals and water-shuttle access.
Choose Naples Bay for on-site pools and organized water activities from the resort's marina.
Hawkaritaville lists a swimming pool and is close to Fort Myers Beach but does not list a private marina or multiple pools.
Hawkaritaville works if you want a basic pool and short beach access rather than a full pool complex and marina services.
Naples Bay offers a full-service spa, fitness centers and on-site nightlife options through restaurants and lounge venues.
If spa services, fitness classes and on-site evening entertainment matter, Naples Bay is the stronger pick.
Hawkaritaville's listing does not publish spa or organized nightlife features; nearby Fort Myers Beach has bars and restaurants within reach.
Pick Hawkaritaville if you plan to spend time on the beach or explore local nightlife rather than rely on on-site wellness services.

Naples Bay — five pools including a zero-entry family pool and lazy river, plus family-friendly dining and shuttle service to the beach.

Naples Bay — on-site marina with boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals and direct bay access.

Hawkaritaville — casual Fort Myers Beach location close to Estero Boulevard Beach and local preserves.

Hawkaritaville — supplier listing notes free self parking onsite, while Naples Bay uses valet with fees.
Naples Bay is better for families — it specifically lists family-friendly pools, a lazy river and kid-friendly dining; Hawkaritaville is a simpler vacation home near the beach.
No. The supplier listing shows Hawkaritaville is not adults-only.
Naples Bay offers multiple on-site restaurants, a registered spa and a large fitness center; Hawkaritaville's listing does not publish on-site restaurants or a spa.
Hawkaritaville lists free self parking onsite; Naples Bay uses valet parking only and charges daily/overnight fees.
Explore how Naples Bay Resort & Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·