
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Best for families and activity seekers who want multiple pools, a lazy river, marina rentals and several on-site dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a larger Tuscan-style waterfront resort in Naples with a marina, multiple pools, on-site restaurants and a full spa — good for families, couples and guests who want resort amenities and water access. The Finn is a small, hotel-like condo option on Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island) that suits travelers who prioritize simple beach proximity and self-contained condo conveniences.
Updated · about 38 miles apart

Best for families and activity seekers who want multiple pools, a lazy river, marina rentals and several on-site dining options.

Best for travelers who want a small, straightforward beachfront-style condo near Fort Myers Beach attractions and independent self-parking.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: Choose Naples Bay if you want resort-scale amenities — five outdoor pools including a lazy river and adults-only pool, an on-site marina with boat and paddle rentals, multiple restaurants, a fitness center and a full-service spa — plus scheduled shuttles to downtown Naples and the beach.
When The Finn wins: Pick The Finn for a lower-key, hotel-like stay on Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island) with immediate proximity to Estero Boulevard Beach, free self parking, a single outdoor pool and simple condo-style conveniences like an in-unit washer/dryer and free Wi‑Fi.
Bottom line: If your priority is a full-service resort experience with beaches reachable by shuttle and lots of on-site activities, Naples Bay is the better fit. If you want a compact, beach-adjacent Fort Myers Beach option and don’t need resort facilities, The Finn is a practical, straightforward choice.
| Category | Naples Bay Resort & Marina | The Finn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort-scale waterfront property with marina, multiple pools and on-site restaurants. | Small, condo-style lodging option on Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island). |
| Location | Naples waterfront near Fifth Avenue South, marina access to Gulf waterways. | Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island) on Estero Boulevard, very close to local beaches and attractions. |
| Size | 85 rooms and suites plus cottages and villas (65 suites noted). | Not published |
| Target guest ages | All ages — family pools and separate adults-only pool/areas. | All ages (not adults-only). |
| Pools | Five outdoor pools including a lazy river, zero-entry family pool, lap pool and adults-only pool/whirlpool. | One outdoor pool. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Nosh on Naples Bay, Blackbird Modern Asian, Indulge, Bluewater Bar & Grill, Café on the Bay). | Not published (unit is condo-style; no supplier-listed signature restaurants). |
| Spa & fitness | The Spa at Naples Bay Club (members/guests only) plus a 2,500 sq ft Wellness & Fitness Center and a smaller hotel gym. | Not published |
| Parking | Valet parking only (daily and overnight fees); resort fee applies for club access. | Free self parking; uncovered parking. |
| Beach access | Shuttle to Naples Beach/Pier; private marina but not beachfront property. | Very close to Estero Boulevard Beach (0.2 mi / 0.3 km listed). |
| Accessibility & check-in | Wheelchair-accessible public areas; standard check-in 4:00 PM, minimum age 21 to check in. | No wheelchair accessibility listed; check-in begins 3:00 PM, minimum check-in age 21. |
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on Naples Bay near Fifth Avenue South with a private marina and scheduled shuttles to the beach and downtown.
Best if you want a central Naples location with marina access and easy trips to downtown and local beaches.
The Finn is on Estero Boulevard in Fort Myers Beach’s Mid Island area, within a short drive or walk of local beaches and attractions.
Best if you want immediate beach-area access on Fort Myers Beach and to be within easy reach of local seaside attractions.
Naples Bay offers a wide range of rooms, suites and cottages with marina or waterway views and family-friendly layouts.
Choose Naples Bay for a broader selection of room sizes and suite/cottage options suitable for families and groups.
The Finn lists condo-style room types such as Family Duplex and Beach View units with in-unit conveniences.
The Finn suits travelers wanting a simple condo setup with in-unit laundry and basic self-contained facilities.
Naples Bay has multiple distinct dining venues serving breakfast through dinner plus a poolside bar.
Pick Naples Bay if you want a range of on-site dining styles from casual poolside to refined waterfront dinner.
The Finn listing does not show on-site signature restaurants; the property functions more like a condo with self-catering convenience.
The Finn works for guests who plan to eat out locally or prepare food in-unit rather than rely on on-site restaurants.
Naples Bay’s pool complex is a major feature, with options for families and adults plus a lazy river.
If pools and a lazy river matter, Naples Bay is the clear choice.
The Finn offers a single outdoor pool and direct proximity to Fort Myers Beach.
The Finn is best for beach-focused visits where you’ll spend time on the sand rather than at a resort pool complex.
Naples Bay provides a full spa and fitness offering plus proximity to Naples dining and nightlife on Fifth Avenue South.
Choose Naples Bay for spa bookings, fitness classes and a wider evening-restaurant scene close by.
The Finn does not publish a spa or fitness center; nighttime options are the nearby Fort Myers Beach restaurants and bars.
The Finn is suitable if you plan to use nearby beach bars and local dining rather than hotel spa or fitness facilities.

Naples Bay — five pools including a zero-entry family pool and lazy river, plus family-friendly dining and on-site activities.

The Finn — located on Estero Boulevard in Fort Myers Beach with the beach a short walk or drive away.

Naples Bay — on-site marina with boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals plus scheduled water shuttle service.

The Finn — small condo-style setup with in-unit washer/dryer, free self-parking and straightforward conveniences.
Naples Bay — it has multiple pools, a lazy river and family-oriented amenities; The Finn is small and more limited in on-site family facilities.
The Finn is on Fort Myers Beach (Mid Island) and is very close to Estero Boulevard Beach; Naples Bay offers shuttle service to Naples Beach and is on a marina rather than directly beachfront.
The Finn listing mentions a washer/dryer in the unit; Naples Bay has cottage and suite options and access to services, but in-room laundry availability depends on the accommodation type.
Naples Bay has multiple on-site restaurants and bars. The Finn’s supplier listing does not publish any on-site restaurants.
Explore how Naples Bay Resort & Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·