
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Best for travelers who want marina access, multiple pool experiences (including a lazy river) and easy walking access to Old Naples dining and shops.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a Tuscan-style waterfront resort in Naples with marina-front suites, cottages, five pools and an on-site marina — read this if you want marina access, multiple pool options, and proximity to downtown Naples. Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa is a full-service, beachfront Hilton on Marco Island with a spa and one outdoor pool — read this if you want a classic beachfront resort with a Hilton rewards feel and onsite spa services.
Updated · about 18 miles (≈29 km) apart

Best for travelers who want marina access, multiple pool experiences (including a lazy river) and easy walking access to Old Naples dining and shops.

Best for travelers whose priority is a beachfront location and a familiar full-service Hilton resort with on-site spa facilities.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: choose Naples Bay when you want a smaller-property feel with marina access, lots of on-site pool options (family lazy river plus adults-only areas), waterfront dining around the bay, and scheduled shuttles to downtown Naples and the beach.
When Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa wins: choose the Hilton when a beachfront location on Marco Island, a larger hotel with traditional full-service resort offerings (onsite spa, pool, bar/restaurant) and the Hilton brand experience are your top priorities.
Bottom line: pick Naples Bay Resort & Marina for a marina-focused Naples stay that’s close to Fifth Avenue South and offers varied pool choices; pick Hilton Marco Island if you prefer staying directly on the sand with standard full-service resort amenities and a larger room inventory.
| Category | Naples Bay Resort & Marina | Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Tuscan-style marina resort with waterfront dining and villa/cottage options | Full-service beachfront Hilton with classic resort facilities |
| Location | Downtown Naples marina / 5th Ave South walking access | South Marco Island beachfront (South End) |
| Size (rooms) | 85 rooms and suites plus cottages/villas | 310 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All-ages resort (family pool + adults-only pool) | All-ages resort (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Five outdoor pools including lazy river, zero-entry family pool, lap pool, adults-only pool and whirlpool | One outdoor pool and a hot tub; wheelchair-accessible pool |
| Beach access | Shuttle to beaches (not beachfront) | Beachfront property (direct beach access) |
| Spa & fitness | The Spa at Naples Bay Club (guest access only), 2,500 sq ft Wellness & Fitness Center plus second hotel gym | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials; fitness facilities (24-hour) |
| Dining & bars | Multiple signature restaurants and a poolside bar (Nosh on Naples Bay, Blackbird Modern Asian, Indulge, BlueWater, Café on the Bay) | Restaurant and coffee shop/cafe on site; bar and poolside bar |
| Accessible rooms & policies | Wheelchair accessible public areas, accessible rooms available; valet parking only | Accessible rooms and features, accessible pool and fitness center; self parking (surcharge) |
| Notable extras | Private marina with 97 slips and boat/kayak/paddleboard rentals, six Har-Tru tennis courts via Naples Bay Club | Nearby sailing, parasailing, paddleboard and boat tours on site or nearby |
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on Naples Bay in the Royal Harbor neighborhood, a short walk to Fifth Avenue South and Tin City.
Best if you want easy walking access to Old Naples restaurants and waterfront shopping plus a marina base for boat outings.
Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa is located on the south end of Marco Island with direct beach access.
Best if your priority is a beachfront stay on Marco Island rather than proximity to downtown Naples.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina offers a mix of rooms, suites and separate cottages for longer or family stays.
Choose Naples Bay for larger multi-room options and cottages suited to families or groups who want separate living space.
Hilton Marco Island lists a broad range of ocean-view and mobility-accessible rooms across its 310 guestrooms.
Choose the Hilton if you want more room availability and standard Hilton room types with ocean-view balconies.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina offers several named waterfront and poolside restaurants plus a café.
Better if you want on-site variety with distinct venues for casual poolside meals and more formal waterfront dinners.
Hilton Marco Island provides on-site restaurant and a coffee shop/cafe plus bar and poolside service.
Choose Hilton Marco Island for reliable, on-property dining and bar options in a beachfront setting; expect fewer distinct signature venues than Naples Bay.
Pools and marina define much of the Naples Bay experience: five outdoor pools, a lazy river and an on-site marina.
Pick Naples Bay for multiple pool settings and marina-based water activities, especially for families and boating-focused stays.
Hilton Marco Island is a beachfront resort with a single outdoor pool, hot tub and direct sand access.
Pick the Hilton for direct beach access and shoreline activities rather than multiple on-site pool types.
Naples Bay Club provides a substantial wellness offering and nights out tend to center on waterfront dining and nearby downtown Naples.
Good for guests who want a full fitness and spa program plus quick access to downtown Naples nightlife and dining.
Hilton Marco Island includes a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities with evening social options onsite.
Choose the Hilton if you want a conventional resort spa program and on-site evening bars in a beachfront setting.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — on-site marina with 97 slips plus boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals.

Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa — a beachfront property with direct access to South Marco Beach.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — five outdoor pools including a lazy river and a zero-entry family pool.

Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa — 310 guestrooms and a full-service resort layout for more standard room choices.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is in Naples and within easy walking distance of Fifth Avenue South and Tin City; the Hilton Marco Island is on Marco Island, a drive away.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is set up for families with a zero-entry family pool and lazy river plus multiple pool options; the Hilton is family-friendly but is primarily a beachfront resort with fewer on-site pools.
Yes — Naples Bay has The Spa at Naples Bay Club (guest access only) and the Hilton Marco Island lists a full-service spa; both recommend booking treatments in advance.
No — the supplier listing shows Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa is not adults-only.
Explore how Naples Bay Resort & Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·