
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Best for families and active travelers who want on-site pools, water sports, and a full resort program.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a waterfront, family-friendly resort with multiple pools, a private marina, and cottages — good for families and anyone who wants on-site activities and water access. Inn on Fifth is a boutique 4-star hotel on Fifth Avenue South that suits travelers who want to be steps from downtown dining, shopping, and a compact hotel experience.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for families and active travelers who want on-site pools, water sports, and a full resort program.

Best for travelers who want to stay on Fifth Avenue South within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and Old Naples attractions.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: choose Naples Bay Resort & Marina if you want more on-site space and activities — five outdoor pools (including a lazy river and adults-only pool), a marina with boat/kayak/paddleboard rentals, tennis courts, and multiple restaurants. It’s set up for families and guests who plan to spend time on property.
When Inn on Fifth wins: choose Inn on Fifth if your priority is being in the middle of Old Naples on Fifth Avenue South with a boutique hotel feel, a full-service spa, and a compact, highly rated downtown stay. It’s convenient for walking to restaurants, galleries, and the beach.
Bottom line: pick Naples Bay Resort & Marina for a full-service resort and water-based amenities; pick Inn on Fifth for location-first stays and a smaller, downtown boutique experience.
| Category | Naples Bay Resort & Marina | Inn on Fifth |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort-scale waterfront property with marina, multiple pools and cottage options | Boutique downtown hotel on Fifth Avenue South; smaller and more intimate |
| Location | 1500 Fifth Ave S, on Naples Bay with marina access; shuttle to downtown and beach | 699 5th Ave S, steps from Fifth Avenue South and close to shops and restaurants |
| Size (rooms & types) | About 85 rooms plus cottages and villas; 65 suites and separate cottage accommodations | 119 guestrooms including Junior Suite, Royal Suite, Club Suites and many view options |
| Audience & age policy | All-ages resort: family pools and adults-only pool; minimum check-in age 21 | All-ages boutique hotel; minimum check-in age 21 per supplier listing |
| Pools & water access | Five outdoor pools including a zero-entry family pool with lazy river, lap pool, and adults-only pool; on-site marina with boat/kayak/paddleboard rentals | Outdoor pool, hot tub and rooftop terrace; complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Nosh on Naples Bay, Blackbird Modern Asian, Indulge, BlueWater Bar & Grill, Café on the Bay, poolside bar) | One restaurant and a bar/lounge; room service available during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Naples Bay Club (spa treatments, sauna, steam rooms) plus 2 fitness centers and fitness classes | Full-service spa offering massages, facials and body treatments; 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Marina-front location, extensive pool complex and on-site activities (tennis, rentals, shuttle) | Central Fifth Avenue South address and strong downtown/Old Naples access |
| Parking & fees | Valet parking only (fees apply); mandatory resort fee covers Naples Bay Club access | Valet parking (surcharge) and optional fees for breakfast and pets per supplier listing |
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on Naples Bay with a private marina and scheduled shuttles to downtown and the beach.
Better if you want direct bay access, marina activities, and a resort spread just outside the downtown core.
Inn on Fifth is a boutique hotel located on Fifth Avenue South in Old Naples, designed for guests who want to be in the middle of downtown.
Better if your priority is walkable access to Old Naples dining, shopping and nightlife.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina has a mix of rooms, suites and separate cottages for guests who want more space or family-friendly layouts.
Choose Naples Bay Resort & Marina for larger accommodations, suites and cottage options.
Inn on Fifth has a wide range of downtown-oriented room types and suites, from Deluxe Double up to multi-room Club and Ambassador suites.
Choose Inn on Fifth for varied suite options and rooms focused on downtown views and convenience.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina offers several waterfront and poolside restaurants, a café and casual pool dining.
Best for travelers who like multiple on-site dining choices without leaving the property.
Inn on Fifth has one main restaurant and a bar/lounge; cooked-to-order breakfasts are available for a fee.
Better for travelers who expect to eat out frequently and want immediate access to downtown restaurants.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina’s headline amenity is its five outdoor pools and lazy river, plus marina activities.
A clear choice if multiple pool experiences and direct boating options matter to you.
Inn on Fifth has an outdoor pool and hot tub, with a complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach.
Better if you want a compact hotel pool and easy walking access to downtown and the beach.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina provides a full wellness program via Naples Bay Club plus casual evening dining and waterfront bars.
Choose Naples Bay Resort & Marina for extensive fitness and spa facilities tied to club access.
Inn on Fifth has a full-service spa and a rooftop terrace; nightlife is primarily the downtown scene on Fifth Avenue.
Pick Inn on Fifth if you want a downtown spa and to be steps from local evening options.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — five pools, lazy river, cottages and family-friendly pool areas.

Inn on Fifth — steps from Fifth Avenue South shops, restaurants and Old Naples attractions.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — on-site marina with boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals and docking.

Inn on Fifth — boutique hotel scale, rooftop terrace, and a high guest rating for downtown stays.
Inn on Fifth is on Fifth Avenue South and is steps from shops and restaurants; Naples Bay Resort & Marina is a short shuttle ride or walk away.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina has a full marina with rental boats, kayaks and paddleboards plus five pools and a lazy river; Inn on Fifth has a pool and beach shuttle but no marina listed.
Yes. Naples Bay Resort & Marina is explicitly family-friendly with kids’ pool options; Inn on Fifth is not adults-only and welcomes families.
Yes. Both properties recommend or require reservations for spa services; Inn on Fifth notes reservations are required for massage services, and Naples Bay Resort & Marina asks guests to book spa treatments in advance.
Explore how Naples Bay Resort & Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·