
Naples Bay Resort & Marina
Best for families and water-sport fans who want marina access, multiple pools and cottage-style rooms.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina is an all-ages, marina-front Tuscan-style resort with multiple pools, a lazy river, cottages and an on-site marina — a good pick for families and active travelers who want water sports and proximity to Fifth Avenue South. Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort is an ultra-luxury beachfront Four Seasons property aimed at travelers who prioritize a branded luxury beach resort experience and full-service spa amenities.
Updated · about 1.2 miles (1.9 km) apart

Best for families and water-sport fans who want marina access, multiple pools and cottage-style rooms.

Best for travelers who want a beachfront, ultra-luxury Four Seasons experience with a dedicated spa and curated resort services.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: choose Naples Bay Resort & Marina if you want easy access to boat, kayak and paddleboard rentals from an on-site marina, multiple pool experiences (including a lazy river and family pool), cottage and multi-bedroom options, and a short walk to Fifth Avenue South.
When Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort wins: choose the Four Seasons if your priority is a branded ultra-luxury beachfront resort with a full-service spa campus, refined dining in a small, high-service property, and direct beach access.
Bottom line: pick Naples Bay Resort & Marina for a lively, activity-focused stay that suits families and small groups, and pick Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort for a quieter, ultra-luxury beach-focused stay with Four Seasons service and on-site spa amenities.
| Category | Naples Bay Resort & Marina | Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Tuscan-style marina resort with family and activity focus | Ultra-luxury beach resort with Four Seasons service |
| Location | 1500 Fifth Ave S, marina-front in Royal Harbor, walkable to Fifth Avenue South | 851 Gulf Shore Blvd N, beachfront (Coquina Sands), steps to the Gulf |
| Size (guestrooms) | 85 rooms and suites, plus cottages and villas (65 suites reported) | 220 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages; family pools and adults-only pool areas via Naples Bay Club | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Five outdoor pools including a lazy river, zero-entry family pool, lap pool, adults-only pool and whirlpool | Two outdoor pools; beach access and beach bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: Nosh on Naples Bay, Blackbird Modern Asian, Indulge Restaurant & Lounge, BlueWater Bar & Grill, Café on the Bay and poolside bar | 2 restaurants, 1 bar/lounge, coffee shop and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Naples Bay Club (guest-only) plus a 2,500 sq ft Wellness & Fitness Center and separate hotel gym | Full-service spa with treatment rooms, steam/sauna and adults-only pool access |
| Known for | Marina with 97 boat slips, water-sport rentals, five pools and shuttle to downtown and the beach | Four Seasons beachfront service, direct beach access and upscale resort amenities |
| Meetings & events | Waterfront ballroom (The Pointe) and roughly 9,000 sq ft combined indoor/outdoor event space | Conference space ~4,390 sq ft with 3 meeting rooms |
| Parking & access | Valet-only parking (fees apply), complimentary shuttles to Naples Beach/Pier and downtown | Secured parking and valet available (covered parking listed); Four Seasons policies include valet fees (supplier listing notes covered valet fee) |
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on a private marina in the Royal Harbor neighborhood near Fifth Avenue South.
Choose this if you want easy marina and downtown access with frequent scheduled shuttle service.
Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort occupies a beachfront spot on Gulf Shore Boulevard with direct beach access.
Choose this if you prioritize being on the beach and a short walk to beachfront attractions.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina offers rooms, many marina-front suites and separate cottage and villa options.
Choose this for more multi-bedroom and cottage-style options when traveling with family or a group.
Naples Beach Club lists 220 guestrooms with a mix of rooms, studios and suites, many offering ocean or partial-ocean views.
Choose this for a wider inventory of traditional luxury hotel rooms with ocean-view categories.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina has several waterfront and poolside dining venues that range from casual to refined.
Choose this for diverse on-site dining options that serve families and dinner-focused evenings on the water.
Naples Beach Club lists two restaurants, one bar/lounge and a coffee shop, plus 24-hour room service.
Choose this if you want a smaller set of high-end dining options and Four Seasons service levels.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina provides a complex of five outdoor pools through Naples Bay Club, including family and adults-only areas.
Choose this for variety—kids can use the lazy river while adults have a separate quiet pool and whirlpool.
Naples Beach Club has two outdoor pools and immediate access to the Gulf beach.
Choose this for direct beach time paired with a smaller, more private pool footprint.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina gives registered guests access to The Spa at Naples Bay Club and fitness facilities via the Club.
Choose this for a broad activity set (tennis, boating, fitness classes) and a guest-only spa tied to the Club.
Naples Beach Club features a full-service spa, fitness facilities and curated resort services common to Four Seasons properties.
Choose this for focused spa offerings, Four Seasons service and a classic beach-resort wellness setup.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — more multi-bedroom cottages and family-focused pools including a lazy river and zero-entry pool.

Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort — direct access to the Gulf and Four Seasons-level beachfront service.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — on-site marina with 97 slips and boat/kayak/paddleboard rentals right from the property.

Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort — a dedicated full-service spa and the smaller, luxury-hotel service model.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina. It offers five pools including a lazy river and zero-entry family pool, cottages and multi-bedroom units that suit families.
Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort is beachfront; Naples Bay Resort & Marina is marina-front with scheduled shuttles to Naples Beach and the Pier.
No day-pass access is listed for The Spa at Naples Bay Club (spa reserved for registered guests and members). Naples Beach Club’s supplier listing notes spa services and reservations but does not publish day-pass availability.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina has a larger on-site dining roster (multiple waterfront, poolside and café options); Naples Beach Club lists two restaurants, a bar/lounge and a coffee shop.
Explore how Naples Bay Resort & Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·